Shambolic Living

  • Home
  • Publications/Media
  • Contact Me
  • About

Woman and Choices

February 12, 2013 By Janine 1 Comment

Julie Bishop

Julie Bishop

The whole “can women have it all” debate is up and running again. Deputy Leader of the Opposition, Julie Bishop, stated in an interview this weekend that women can’t have it all.

“I’m in the Anne-Marie Slaughter school – women can’t have it all. They can have plenty of choices, but at the end of the day, they choose something which means they can’t have something else”.

In Bishop’s case she had expected to have children but “the circumstances didn’t arise”.  As it turns out she says

“I feel incredibly lucky that I’ve had the kind of career that is so consuming that I don’t feel I have a void in my life”.

Last week Attorney General, Nicola Roxon, announced she was resigning from politics to spend more time with her young daughter.

If one of the aims of feminism was to allow women more choices then I think many women can safely tick that box. We have countless more options than the generations before us, where I think it fell down a little was on the logistics.

How to successfully integrate those choices into family life  is one tough gig.

Workplaces are still coming to terms with flexibility (which I would rate as the number one requirement for any working parent). Labor is trying to extend the right to ask for flexible work arrangements from just parents with a pre-schooler or a disabled child to parents of all school-aged children, and those caring for elderly relatives.

Going out a limb here, until we can  sort out the “how” of implementing our choices I think women are always going to struggle with this bloody “having it all” debate.

While women argue over the importance of claiming the word “feminist” and dither about in ridiculous battles over breastfeeding vs bottle-feeding and stay-at-home vs go back to work we are neglecting a pretty crucial issue.

True equality will only emerge when men are as committed to the cause as women.

In Western society* we are not going to get there by storming the barricades, we did that (thank you suffragettes and 70’s feminists who had to break the doors) but we are through many of the doors now and we urgently need a new strategy.

A new strategy needs to include men in the equation. A report from Diversity Council Australia show men want  access to flexible work as well and I’m sure if you also asked men and women without children they too could find benefits in a more flexible workplace, to take further study, care for an ageing parent, or write the great Australian novel.

Flexibility benefits everyone. Yes, even the employers, who will find  less absenteeism and turnover, and improved worker health and productivity  if they allow a little leeway when needed.

There are still many matters to be resolved equal pay, career advancement after maternity leave, superannuation to name a few, but with women still in low numbers  in leadership positions we need to start to look at why women aren’t pursuing the power, and figure out a way to overcome it. Again, I think it’s going to have to be a team effort.

Yesterday over at the Hoopla, Lisa Lintern put out a call for more male feminists. I’m not sure how many blokes would be willing to put their hands up as a feminist (I think it’s also time we acknowledged feminism has an image problem and needs a re-branding). However, I think if you asked men if their daughters, sisters, wives  deserved equal standing to men they would happily agree.

Also at the Hoopla, Tracey Spicer argued Bishop’s comment took us back to a 1950’s attitude. However, I think when women in the powerful, high-profile, well paid jobs are struggling with the situation there isn’t a lot of hope for those of us at the bottom of the food-chain.

Is it possible in 2013 to see a greater collaboration between men and women on creating a workplace that embraces the talents and skills of ALL its participants and makes combining work and life a more achievable prospect? Or am I just dreaming?

*I’m well aware that in other countries in the world there are still huge barriers to women’s equality (and safety), this post is speaking specifically of  the “having it all”, work/life balance discussion that so often arises in Western society.

 

 

Filed Under: Employment, Family Tagged With: having it all, Julie Bishop, work/life balance

« Monday Morning Photo – Ouch
Sweet Sixteen »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Janine Fitzpatrick is a personal blogger with an untidy house, imperfect children and no celebrity friends.

Follow Me

FACEBOOK

Looking For Something?

Categories

Archives

Weekend Notes

WATCHINGI went to see Fiona O'Loughlin last night. She's the comedian who survived alcoholism, a two week coma from not realising, in her drunken state, that the heater in the dive she was living in was leaking carbon monoxide.  Then went on to spend … [Read More...]

Weekend Notes

Watching We headed to the movies this weekend and saw the latest Spike Lee film, BlacKkKlansman. It's the story of the first black cop in the Colorado Springs police force, Ron Stallworth, who in the late 70's managed to infiltrate the Ku Klux … [Read More...]

Sleepless

So I've been awake since 3.00am. In that time I've signed the family up for an organizing app which can run a joint calendar, shared shopping and to-do lists and has downloaded a series of recipes that are supposed to make my "what's for dinner" … [Read More...]

Grey stairs.

The Widow Goes On A Date

The last time I went on a first date Bob Hawke was Prime Minister, Liam Hemsworth was being born, Madonna was singing Vogue on the radio, Macaulay Culkin was being left Home Alone and Kevin Costner was Dancing with Wolves. It was a long time ago … [Read More...]

Father with two daughters.

Another Father’s Day

Hi Simon, How's things going up there? Did you have a beer with your Dad for Father's Dad? We blatantly ignored the day here. Just pretended it wasn't happening. We still think about you every day. I didn't post anything on Facebook because it … [Read More...]

Daisy flowers

Hellooo Again

  Hi, I'm just here unwrapping the dust covers, brushing down the spiderwebs and sweeping up the left-over dreams of my tiny little space on the internet. I know I've been gone almost 12-months. I'm not even sure how that happened. A … [Read More...]

A messy scrapbooking desk

Milestone Moments

Hey Simon, Despite my best intentions to ignore the milestones they keep on happening, with or without you. We celebrated your Mum's 80th birthday back in August. A rushed trip of some 1,850 kilometres all up with just four days to do the 9 hour … [Read More...]

Weekend Notes

What have you been up to this weekend? Watching  We caught Home Again in the cinema. It's the latest Reese Witherspoon film.  It's a fun little comedy. Reese plays Alice a just-turned 40 divorcing mum of two. At her birthday drinks she … [Read More...]

Picture of a beach.

Weekend Notes

  As the weekend draws to a close here's a little of what caught my eye in the last 48 hours. Watching Saw Battle of the Sexes the new Emma Stone movie about the 1973 tennis match between Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs. Oh what a time … [Read More...]

A Bag of chips, wine, chocolate, lemonade and magazine. A parody of a bug out bag for the apocalypse.

Could You Survive The Apocalypse?

South Koreans are buying "survival bags" and turning to YouTube for tips on making it through a nuclear blast. The New York Times is writing articles on How To Survive The Apocalypse and the doomsday preppers are starting to look like the smart ones. … [Read More...]

chocolate and wine

Home Alone: The Empty Nest

The empty nest looms in my near future. One more year before the youngest heads out into the world without my micromanaging her every move. I can feel the rotor blades on my helicopter starting to slow.   I heard a whisper of what may … [Read More...]

Weekend Notes

It's a long weekend here in Australia.  So it's been a lazy time. Perfect for some catch-up TV, movies and reading.   Watching I've been enjoying Doctor Doctor it was shot in my old hometown of Mudgee and gosh it's looking … [Read More...]

iVillage

Janine Fitzpatrick is a personal blogger with an untidy house, imperfect children and no celebrity friends. Read More…

Grey stairs.
Father with two daughters.

Copyright © 2025 ·Foodie Child Theme · Genesis Framework by StudioPress · WordPress · Log in